Knives out against Kalyan Banerjee, will Mamata’s ‘shield’ work again?
Knives Out Against Kalyan Banerjee: Can Mamata’s Political Shield Save Him Again?
Kalyan Banerjee, one of Trinamool Congress’s most seasoned faces and a sitting Member of Parliament from Serampore, finds himself in the eye of a growing political storm. Known for his fiery speeches and courtroom wit, Banerjee is no stranger to controversy. However, recent political developments within West Bengal and the rising discontent within his own party ranks suggest that his political career might be at a crossroads. As dissent brews and opposition sharpens its knives, the question that looms large is—will Mamata Banerjee, the party’s indomitable leader, step in to shield him once again?
Rising Tensions Within TMC
Tensions within the Trinamool Congress (TMC) have been simmering ever since Banerjee’s remarks about constitutional authorities and religious sensitivities drew national criticism. While TMC has traditionally stood by its veteran leaders during controversies, this time the murmurs of dissent from within the party’s younger leadership indicate that patience might be wearing thin.
Sources close to the party’s internal affairs have hinted that a growing section of TMC MLAs and MPs are uncomfortable with Banerjee’s combative style, fearing it gives ammunition to the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ahead of crucial elections. His controversial comments, some say, overshadow the party’s welfare initiatives and developmental achievements in West Bengal.
Public Image and Political Weight
Despite the growing criticism, Banerjee remains a significant political force. His deep connect with the grassroots, particularly in the Hooghly belt, and his courtroom acumen have helped TMC in key legal battles. Political analysts argue that cutting him loose may create a vacuum in regions where his influence is still substantial.
“Mamata Banerjee has always valued loyalty and grassroots strength. Kalyan Banerjee, despite his flaws, brings both to the table,” says Kolkata-based political analyst Shuvra Roy. “However, the current climate within the party demands more restraint and less firebrand politics.”
BJP’s Calculated Offensive
The BJP has seized the opportunity with both hands. Its leaders have launched a sustained campaign targeting Banerjee, painting him as the symbol of TMC’s alleged arrogance and intolerance. Leaders like Suvendu Adhikari and Dilip Ghosh have amplified the issue at every turn, hoping to consolidate Hindu votes and weaken TMC’s secular pitch.
“Banerjee’s statements hurt the sentiments of many. Mamata Banerjee must decide if she supports such behavior,” said Adhikari during a recent rally in Howrah. The saffron party’s repeated jabs signal a calculated move to isolate Banerjee and pressure Mamata into taking action.
Mamata’s Calculated Silence
What stands out in this entire saga is Mamata Banerjee’s silence. Unlike previous instances where she rushed to defend her party members, this time her response has been notably measured. Insiders suggest that the TMC supremo is watching the political pulse carefully, trying to balance the party’s image with internal dynamics.
While Banerjee still enjoys support among old guard leaders, the younger generation, led by Abhishek Banerjee, is said to be pushing for a more progressive and disciplined public stance. This inter-generational clash within the TMC could influence Mamata’s final decision.
Public Sentiment and Grassroots Reality
Despite the controversies, Banerjee continues to command respect among his constituency. “He speaks the truth, even if it stings,” says Sushmita Dey, a local schoolteacher from Serampore. “Not everyone likes his words, but people know he works for them.”
This local support acts as a cushion, allowing Banerjee to withstand high-level criticism. But as elections near, the party leadership is also aware that public perception in urban and undecided voter bases could tilt the balance.
Opposition Unity and Legal Hurdles
Adding to Banerjee’s woes is the possibility of a coordinated legal challenge. Several public interest litigations (PILs) have already been filed against him, and the opposition parties are keen to keep the spotlight on him. The Congress and CPI(M) may be out of power, but they continue to press for disciplinary action and probe into his remarks.
The courts have yet to act decisively, but any legal action—even symbolic—could become a thorn in the side of TMC’s clean governance image.
Mamata’s Political Dilemma
Mamata Banerjee is no stranger to making tough decisions. From sacking ministers to reshuffling portfolios, she has shown an iron hand when required. However, her emotional connection with long-time loyalists like Kalyan Banerjee makes this episode more complex.
If she chooses to stand by him, she risks alienating younger TMC leaders and giving opposition parties fresh fodder. On the other hand, distancing herself from Banerjee could fracture the party’s traditional support base in regions like Serampore and further escalate internal factionalism.
What Lies Ahead?
For now, Banerjee continues to hold his ground, refusing to apologize or tone down his rhetoric. Whether this defiance will work in his favor or backfire spectacularly remains to be seen. What’s clear is that the knives are indeed out—and the coming weeks will be critical in shaping his political future.
Observers believe that Mamata Banerjee might opt for a middle path—issuing a public rebuke while retaining Banerjee’s formal position. This would allow her to signal accountability without risking a grassroots backlash.
As West Bengal inches toward another politically charged season, the spotlight will remain fixed on Kalyan Banerjee. Will the veteran survive yet another storm, or has the party finally run out of patience? Only time—and Mamata’s next move—will tell.
