Dehradun defence coaching institute accused of making student do 400 sit-ups for ‘talking in class’

A shocking incident at a defence coaching institute in Dehradun has sparked national outrage. An 18-year-old student from Meghalaya, who moved to the city to prepare for defence exams, was allegedly punished with 400 sit-ups for talking during a class.

The student attended the coaching institute with high hopes, but a routine mathematics class on July 4 took a disturbing turn. The teacher, Jai Singh, ordered the student to perform 400 sit-ups as punishment. This physically intense task left the student with severe leg pain, swelling, and muscle spasms.

Medical Treatment and Legal Complaint

Unable to walk properly, the student sought medical help. Doctors admitted him to a hospital, where orthopedic specialists confirmed muscle fatigue due to extreme physical exertion. His parents filed a police complaint in Shillong on July 14, which the authorities later forwarded to Vasant Vihar Police Station in Dehradun.

The local police registered an FIR on July 21. The complaint claimed the institute offered only a written apology and took no disciplinary action against the teacher.

Legal Experts React

Lawyers familiar with education law weighed in on the matter. They said the punishment could fall under Section 323 of the Indian Penal Code, which deals with voluntarily causing hurt. The teacher and institute could both face legal action if investigators prove negligence or intent to harm.

Although the student is legally an adult, his vulnerable position as a dependent learner brings additional concerns under education and child protection guidelines.

Toxic Culture in Coaching Institutes

This case is not isolated. Dehradun, known for its growing coaching industry, has seen multiple similar incidents in recent years. Some students have reported being slapped, locked in classrooms, or harassed by seniors in the name of discipline.

In 2022, government inspectors found that several coaching centres in Dehradun were operating without valid licenses. Many lacked proper infrastructure, safety systems, and grievance redressal procedures.

The Mental and Physical Toll

Students preparing for defence exams often face intense academic pressure. Many push themselves through long study hours and physical training. When teachers cross the line with extreme punishments, students suffer both mentally and physically.

In this case, the student’s hospitalization exposed the serious risk such punishments pose. Instead of building character, such discipline breaks trust and damages health.

Public Outrage and Media Attention

The incident quickly gained media coverage. Social media users expressed anger and called for strict punishment for those responsible. Education activists also condemned the coaching institute and demanded better monitoring of such private institutions.

Former students from similar institutes came forward with stories of mistreatment. Many said they never spoke out due to fear of expulsion or ridicule.

Ongoing Police Investigation

Police officials visited the coaching centre and recorded statements from students and staff. According to initial reports, the authorities believe the allegations hold weight. Investigators are gathering medical records, CCTV footage, and written communication between the parents and the institute.

The teacher may soon face questioning. If evidence confirms wrongdoing, the case could lead to charges not just against the teacher but also against the institute’s management.

Why Oversight Is Urgent

India’s coaching industry operates in a legal grey area. Despite its rapid growth, few centres face routine inspections. Many parents send their children to such institutes, believing these places will prepare them for competitive exams. But without regulation, some institutions abuse that trust.

This incident should push policymakers to establish clear rules. These rules must protect students from abuse while ensuring quality education and training.

Conclusion: Discipline Should Not Be Abuse

The Dehradun case highlights the dangers of unchecked authority in educational spaces. While discipline is important, it must not come at the cost of a student’s physical or emotional well-being.

As investigations continue, the student’s family hopes for justice. Their son came to Dehradun to serve the country one day—but instead, he ended up in a hospital bed. It is time to ensure that no other student suffers in the name of discipline.