‘Before whom did India surrender?’: Gaurav Gogoi leads Opposition charge

New Delhi, July 29 — The Parliament witnessed tense moments on Monday as Congress MP Gaurav Gogoi strongly criticized the central government. His sharp question, “Before whom did India surrender?” ignited a fierce political exchange during the ongoing session.

Gogoi questioned Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s earlier claim that “no one has entered Indian territory.” The Congress leader argued that this statement ignores ground realities. Reports and images show Chinese presence in areas like Eastern Ladakh. Gogoi said the government must explain the silence around Chinese actions on Indian soil.

Gogoi’s Bold Question Sparks Debate

Gaurav Gogoi didn’t mince words. While speaking in Lok Sabha, he reminded everyone of the 2020 Galwan Valley clash. He noted that 20 Indian soldiers died defending the border. Despite the sacrifice, the Prime Minister stated that no one crossed into Indian territory. Gogoi asked Parliament and the people to reflect on the contradiction.

“The Prime Minister says no one entered. Then why did soldiers die? Before whom did India surrender?” he asked.

His statement triggered loud reactions from BJP members. Many tried to interrupt, but Gogoi continued without backing down. He demanded transparency and said Parliament has the right to know the truth.

Opposition Seeks Answers on China

For over three years, the Opposition has raised questions about China’s actions along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). Congress leaders have asked for detailed updates on the border situation. They believe the government is hiding facts under the pretext of national security.

Gogoi stressed that asking questions doesn’t weaken India. Instead, it strengthens democracy. He said Parliament must not remain in the dark while foreign troops occupy disputed areas.

“We are not asking for battle plans. We want clarity. Why is the government afraid to speak openly?” Gogoi asked.

BJP Defends Government’s Stand

Soon after Gogoi’s remarks, BJP leaders came to the government’s defence. Union Minister Kiren Rijiju said the Opposition was playing politics with national security. He claimed the Indian Army is well-prepared and the government has taken firm steps.

“Our soldiers are alert. The government has built roads and increased defence spending. This is not the time to spread doubt,” Rijiju said.

He also criticized Gogoi’s tone. Rijiju said such statements could demoralize soldiers guarding the border.

The Galwan Legacy Still Haunts

The Galwan Valley clash in June 2020 was one of the deadliest India-China confrontations in decades. While both countries later agreed to disengage, reports suggest Chinese forces still occupy key points. Areas like Depsang and Demchok continue to see tension.

Despite multiple military talks, the situation remains unresolved. Independent analysts and satellite images indicate a slow Chinese buildup in sensitive zones.

The Opposition says the government’s silence gives the impression that all is well, which they believe is misleading.

Is India Losing Ground Silently?

Opposition leaders worry that India may be ceding territory without public knowledge. Gogoi and others argue that the government is more focused on image than integrity. They accuse the BJP of choosing political optics over national interest.

In contrast, the government says public statements may impact diplomatic efforts. Officials argue that talking openly could escalate tensions.

This clash of views continues to shape the debate in Parliament.

Elections on the Horizon

With state elections nearing and the 2026 general election approaching, the China issue could become a major talking point. The Opposition wants to portray the government as weak and secretive. They hope this strategy will help them connect with voters, especially those concerned with national pride and security.

The BJP, on the other hand, highlights its investments in defence infrastructure. They believe their track record speaks for itself.

Call for Transparency Grows Stronger

Gogoi urged the government to share facts in a closed-door session if public disclosure is not possible. He said the people have the right to know whether Indian territory is secure.

“We are not enemies of the state. We are asking for answers on behalf of citizens,” he said.

Defence experts agree that a balance is needed. Sharing too much could hurt national interests, but complete silence creates confusion.

Conclusion: A Debate That Won’t Fade

Gaurav Gogoi’s question—“Before whom did India surrender?”—has added fuel to a long-standing political fire. As both sides stick to their positions, the demand for transparency continues to grow.

The border issue with China remains unresolved. Parliament may debate it for weeks to come, but only time will tell whether the government chooses to speak with more clarity.